English
English
Español
Français

User Access


Ad alt tag
McElroy Metals -  Ad - May 2022
English
English
Español
Français

German Style, clay tile roof with counter batten, copper gutter with mountain roof hanger, copper down spouts, and torch down

« Back To Roofers Talk
Author
Posts
August 3, 2010 at 12:10 p.m.

TomB

OMG....I'm at a loss for words....

So, I take it, your were the "consultant" on the project?....You must have been brought in after the contract award? Did the owners not solicit qualified roofers?

August 3, 2010 at 11:10 a.m.

Martin

TomB Said: Yes; Refreshing to see a properly installed tile roof....How fortunate to have the opportunity to install a tile roof correctly!....That would never fly here, in the land of knuckleheadness....One would be laughed off the project....

Just to clarify....3600SF & the price was $180,0000? For that knd of money, we could have done at least three, possibly four, of those roofs/homes.....Not to take away the fine craftmanship, it appears to be truly top-notch....However, coming strictly from a financial/ethical aspect, how can you sleep? Or did the customer knowingly pay the absurd amount?

Sorry this missunderstanding it was not my price !!!!! Some roofer in Boston provide this roof between 120000$ & 160000 $ O N L Y for the labor !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

August 3, 2010 at 10:50 a.m.

TomB

Yes; Refreshing to see a properly installed tile roof....How fortunate to have the opportunity to install a tile roof correctly!....That would never fly here, in the land of knuckleheadness....One would be laughed off the project....

Just to clarify....3600SF & the price was $180,0000? For that knd of money, we could have done at least three, possibly four, of those roofs/homes.....Not to take away the fine craftmanship, it appears to be truly top-notch....However, coming strictly from a financial/ethical aspect, how can you sleep? Or did the customer knowingly pay the absurd amount?

August 3, 2010 at 9:41 a.m.

robert

My point was against that tile roof the modified might as well been roll roofing,it does not compliment the tile at all.

August 3, 2010 at 8:14 a.m.

tico

CIAK Said: Martin Im going to pay you the highest compliment I know. I love beautiful well designed things. There’s very little in the world quite like something that was lovingly crafted, built with care and presented with this sort of pride. A marvelously well built roof. A marvelously well built roof is increasingly difficult to come by in a world where a premium is placed on speed, and things are made to be disposable. Good job. A work of art by a true Craftsman. Congrats my man. B) :) :) B)
I forgot completely to comend you for this job.I second CIAK,loudly.your A big asset to what I speak of when people want to say to me "it's just A roof.and now,we see the modern mingle with the ancient and walla,Martin breathes. I think it's gorgeous,and I also like that other roofers take the same pride doing their jobs.my hats off to the roof man who does and knows his job.

my previous comment was of the price,out of curiosity,was it 18.000.00 or 180.000.00. thats all.

August 3, 2010 at 8:11 a.m.

Martin

Robert Said: Why not put a copper roof on the front?Its nice but the that flat should have been copper.

sorry, but the client didn`t want to much copper

August 3, 2010 at 8:10 a.m.

Martin

CIAK Said: Martin Im going to pay you the highest compliment I know. I love beautiful well designed things. There’s very little in the world quite like something that was lovingly crafted, built with care and presented with this sort of pride. A marvelously well built roof. A marvelously well built roof is increasingly difficult to come by in a world where a premium is placed on speed, and things are made to be disposable. Good job. A work of art by a true Craftsman. Congrats my man. B) :) :) B)

Thank`s a lot, maybe we can sometimes work together when you need some help

August 3, 2010 at 8:01 a.m.

robert

Why not put a copper roof on the front?Its nice but the that flat should have been copper.

August 3, 2010 at 7:53 a.m.

CIAK

Martin I'm going to pay you the highest compliment I know. I love beautiful well designed things. There’s very little in the world quite like something that was lovingly crafted, built with care and presented with this sort of pride. A marvelously well built roof. A marvelously well built roof is increasingly difficult to come by in a world where a premium is placed on speed, and things are made to be disposable. Good job. A work of art by a true Craftsman. Congrats my man. B) :) :) B)

August 3, 2010 at 7:20 a.m.

Martin

jimAKAblue Said: One question comes to mind about the roof flashing. Im curious about the flashing detail at the apron flashing that butts up to the dormer. When I framed, I always left a minimum of 4 below the window. Thats not possible on this house. Is caulk the only solution?

I know this, it was a problem, but we haven`t had an other change !!!

But it will never leaking under and behind the window is a special peace of copper.

August 3, 2010 at 7:16 a.m.

Martin

lanny Said: ---180k Wow!!! For that price I would have expected it to be over 100 sq & 12/12. ---Many compliments on what looks great. I dont do any of that kind of work but it is impressive. Lanny

That roof has had 3600 sqft

August 3, 2010 at 7:15 a.m.

Martin

jimAKAblue Said: Im impressed! Theres a lot of components that Ive never had any experience with.

Im also a bit shocked with the pricetag. I think I want to start selling tile and copper roofs!

I do have extensive experience framing, so I have a few questions. Unfortunately, Im not sure what the framing parts are called, by roofers. Ill make my best guess.

Im curious about the 1/3 furring strips. Im assuming that these are located directly over the rafters. Are they?

Do you bed the furr strips in sealant? Is there any danger of water getting trapped under the furr strips and causing mold or rotting them out?

Picture 5 shows a built up rake assembly? Was there some reason why a solid member, such as a 2x8 (or a ripped down 2x10) wasnt used? Was that a change in design or scope?

Thats enough questions for one day.

It`s my job to do consultation and those roof`s. The strips are all sealed and nailed on the rafters. The reason why I use two pices of hipp batten is , to do the right high for the hipp and ridge tiles.

August 3, 2010 at 7:09 a.m.

Martin

tico Said: maybe 18,000

18,000 ?????????????????

August 3, 2010 at 7:07 a.m.

Martin

Vaa Fakaosifolau Said: looks nice :cheer:

Cant you get Red colured Torchon in the USA? To match the tiles. All the European manufacturers do a Red or Terracotta colour..

Spose the grey will kind of match the copper when it patinas though

I tried it, but I didn`t get red torchon. In Germany you can buy dark brown. So I used the white one

August 3, 2010 at 4:40 a.m.

tico

maybe 18,000


« Back To Roofers Talk
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Coffee Conversations - Banner Ad - Roofing & Homes for our Troops On Demand (Sponsored by ABC Supply)
English
English
Español
Français

User Access


McElroy Metals -  Ad - May 2022
Ad alt tag

Loading…
Loading the web debug toolbar…
Attempt #